Smothering Tithe — Commander Masters printing

Smothering Tithe Proxy

Enchantment · Commander Masters · mythic

Real card
$63.20
Proxy single
$0.50
save 99%

$0.40/card in a full imported deck, $2.00 in rainbow foil. S33 German Black Core playtest card — not for sanctioned play.

Real-card format legality

commander: Legallegacy: Legalvintage: Legalmodern: Legalpauper: Not legal

Proxies themselves are never sanctioned-legal — this is the real card's status, useful for Rule-0 talks. Proxy legality, explained

Printings (13)

We match the exact printing's artwork from Scryfall — pick any of these in the singles builder.

Set#ReleasedReal price
Secret Lair Drop70092025-03-30$704
Wilds of Eldraine: Enchanting Tales672023-09-08$207
Wilds of Eldraine: Enchanting Tales872023-09-08$1,127
Wilds of Eldraine: Enchanting Tales132023-09-08$62.08
Commander Masters4732023-08-04
Commander Masters572023-08-04$63.00
Commander Masters6932023-08-04$72.78
Judge Gift Cards 202252022-07-12$116
Double Masters 20224232022-07-08
Double Masters 20223422022-07-08$71.42
Double Masters 2022312022-07-08$56.20
Ravnica Allegiance222019-01-25$49.95
Ravnica Allegiance Promos22p2019-01-25$56.84

Frequently asked

How much does a real Smothering Tithe cost?

Around $63.20 on the open market for the Commander Masters printing (price snapshot 2026-07-21; live prices move daily).

How much does a Smothering Tithe proxy cost?

$0.50 as a single on an 18-card sheet, $0.40 when it's part of a full imported deck, or $2.00 in rainbow foil — all on S33 German Black Core cardstock, shipped from New York.

Can I play a Smothering Tithe proxy?

As a playtest card, yes — in casual Commander pods, kitchen-table games, and proxy-friendly events, with your playgroup's OK. Proxies are not legal in sanctioned tournaments, and we print them for personal, non-sanctioned play only.

Players also proxy