Is Proxy Prints legit?
Fair question — you're about to send money to an internet print shop. Short answer: Proxy Prints LLC is a registered US company run by its owner, orders ship from New York, and everything about how we operate is published where you can check it. Here's how to verify us yourself.
The company
Proxy Prints LLC prints Magic: The Gathering playtest proxies on S33 German Black Core cardstock, and orders ship from New York. The shop is owner-run: Mark handles orders, support email, and quality problems personally. Payments run through mainstream processors (Visa, Mastercard, Amex, Discover, Apple Pay, Google Pay), every order ships with a tracking number, and our shipping policy states real delivery windows up front — we're deliberately a slow-and-affordable shop, not a rush service.
Verify us in two minutes
- Reviews: our Google Business Profile is public — read what customers say.
- Customer photos: @mtgproxyprints on Instagram shows real printed decks.
- Talk to a human first: support@proxy-prints.com — the owner answers.
Not affiliated with similarly named proxy sites
The proxy-printing space is crowded with lookalike names. Proxy Prints (shop.proxy-prints.com) is not affiliated with PrintingProxies.com, ProxyPrinters.com, ProxyPrintery, PrintMTG, ProxyKing, or MakePlayingCards. Reviews, complaints, and policies you read about those companies — good or bad — are about different businesses. When in doubt, check the domain: we only sell at shop.proxy-prints.com.
Frequently asked
Is Proxy Prints a real company?
Yes. Proxy Prints LLC is a registered US limited-liability company run by its owner, Mark. Orders are printed on S33 German Black Core cardstock and ship from New York with tracking numbers, and payment is handled by mainstream card processors (Visa, Mastercard, Amex, Discover, Apple Pay, Google Pay).
How can I verify Proxy Prints before ordering?
Check our public Google Business Profile reviews, look through customer photos on Instagram (@mtgproxyprints), and read our plainly published shipping policy — we state real delivery windows instead of promising rush turnaround. If you want to talk to a person first, email support@proxy-prints.com and the owner answers.
Is Proxy Prints the same company as PrintingProxies, ProxyPrinters.com, or ProxyPrintery?
No. Proxy Prints (shop.proxy-prints.com) is not affiliated with PrintingProxies.com, ProxyPrinters.com, ProxyPrintery, PrintMTG, ProxyKing, or MakePlayingCards. Several proxy vendors have confusingly similar names; reviews and complaints about those companies are about different businesses.
Are the cards legal to own?
Proxies for personal, casual use occupy a well-established space in the Magic community: they are playtest cards, not counterfeits, and we clearly position them that way — never for sanctioned tournaments and never for resale as genuine cards. Our guide 'Are MTG Proxies Legal?' walks through Wizards of the Coast's actual policy in detail.
What if something is wrong with my order?
Email support@proxy-prints.com. Misprints and quality problems are fixed by the owner directly — that's the practical advantage of an owner-run shop. Our shipping policy page documents current production and delivery timelines so you know what to expect before you order.
Still deciding? Start with the proxy legality guide or price out a deck on the import page — no account needed.